Should Portage and Main be reopened to pedestrian traffic

 

Portage and main in the winter time is a cold, windy not to mention slippery place to try and walk.

 

Songs have been written about it.

It has been the venue for public rallies.

Originally an ox cart crossing in the late 1800’s  Portage and Main has evolved into Winnipeg’s most iconic intersection.

My first memories of Portage and Main date back to the early 1970’s  when I was a new recruit with the Winnipeg Police Force (as it was then called) .

Police recruits attended classes in the morning.  The classroom was located on the 5th floor of the Public Safety Building.  Then in the afternoon recruits were assigned to walk beats in the downtown area and of course do traffic duty.

Some of the most dreaded traffic points were Portage and Donald, Mayfair and Main and of course the biggy:  Portage and Main.

Portage and Donald was not all that problematic except for the fact that is was the route used by the then Deputy Chief J. C. Webster to make his way home and the poor Constable doing traffic duty there needed not only to try and keep traffic flowing smoothly but also had to keep a sharp eye out for the Deputy’s car.  The Deputy liked to be saluted and in that era hell had no fury like a Deputy not saluted.

Then of course there was Mayfair and Main.  That intersection was a two-person job.  One recruit would be out in the middle of the street actually directing traffic, and the second would manually operate the traffic signal box changing the traffic control signals from green to amber to red based on traffic flow.  What made this intersection dicey was that the Superintendent in charge of Training and Personnel (Charles S Tully) and the Sergeant Instructor (Thomas Arfield) both rode the bus home along Main Street and woe be to the Constables who failed to facilitate an orderly flow of traffic especially the traffic that was south bound on Main street.

Then there was Portage and Main.  The intersection from hell in terms of traffic and traffic duty.  The constable assigned the task had to juggle three lanes of traffic approaching Main street from Portage Avenue east bound, and Main Street both north and south bound as well as a lesser flow of traffic from East Portage Avenue heading west.   Controlling those wanting to turn left, right or proceed straight through was bad enough but then add pedestrians to the mix and it was a nightmare.  Due to the cold conditions in the winter, pedestrians invariably kept crossing the street well after the don’t walk signal came on and because of the congestion in the area, drivers kept entering the intersection when the traffic light turned amber and well beyond.  The result was gridlock and of course many close calls including the occasional accident involving cars and pedestrians.  With all the honking of horns,  and pedestrians shouting at drivers it was like being in New York.

The closing of Portage and Main to pedestrian traffic in 1978 was a major step forward in terms of pedestrian safety and traffic flow in downtown Winnipeg.

Now our Mayor who was knee high to a grasshopper when the change was made wants to stage a nostalgic ‘back to the future’ and reopen Portage and Main to pedestrians.  Using the words of an actor from a movie some years back: ‘big mistake, huge’.

The City has grown substantially since 1978 (by approximately 150,000) and traffic flow which was a problem then is an even greater issue now.   The re-opening or Portage and Main to pedestrian traffic would be a great plan if your end objective was to bog down the center of Winnipeg into a total rush hour gridlock and at the same time endanger the lives of pedestrians.

So if that is your objective, Mayor Bowman, the re-opening of Portage and Main to pedestrian traffic will be a booming success.  Have at it.

Oh, and by the way, how about a few hitching posts – they used to have those along Main Street as well. 

Advertisements

16 comments on “Should Portage and Main be reopened to pedestrian traffic

  1. x says:

    Good Afternoon Menno,

    Thank you for sending me your comments regarding Portage & Main. There are a number of aspects to this debate and I appreciate the opportunity to let you know where the discussion is at.
    Due to the 40-year lease agreement with the property owners on the corners expiring in 2019, there are matters regarding the intersection that have to be dealt with presently.
    Despite some confusion in the media, the administrative report currently before City Council deals with a limited aspect of the intersection and does not authorize the removal of the barriers and installation of cross-walks.

    Bottom line; there will NOT be pedestrians crossing the intersection next week (or any time soon).

    Some of the monies being requested will fund needed repairs and maintenance to the 40-year old public space below the intersection (such as removing mold, water leaks and other minor structural repairs).
    The administrative report also requests funds to get a firmer estimate and engineering requirements to more accurately know the potential costs of opening the intersection to pedestrians.

    Last week I introduced a motion at Executive Policy Committee to make sure that Council will have all the information needed so that (when the time comes) we can have an informed debate before voting whether or not to re-open the intersection to pedestrians.
    The motion reads;

    “That prior to reintroducing pedestrians at-grade the public service be required to return to City Council for approval with a plan for reintroduction of pedestrians that includes cost estimates, transit and traffic implications”

    My motion was adopted and is now included in the report that will be discussed and voted on Wednesday at the full City Council meeting.

    Until we have that full data, the intersection will remain closed.

    Thank you again for your email. If you have any additional comments or questions, please let me know.

    Kind Regards,

    Scott Gillingham
    City Councillor
    St James-Brooklands-Weston ward

  2. J Graham says:

    What a crazy idea! Who came up with this? Obviously no one who has ever tried to walk across that intersection, ever. It was especially harrowing in the windswept icy winter that Winnipeggers get to enjoy every year! Give your head a shake!!

  3. Darlene says:

    Seems like another waste of money. Why would you? There is already a way! Spread some of the improvements to areas, other then downtown…encourage use of other areas instead of cramming everyone in one area. Why not determine a way to promote living within walking or cycling distance or busing route to their work places. Ie a bonus “environmental ambassador” wage added to their regular wages for people who live in the area to reduce traffic…

  4. Wayne Piche says:

    mr bowman will be responsible for every pedestrian accident and death. if he want’s to live with those consequences, like you said, have at it.

  5. x says:

    There is a saying in political circles that “if it saves one life it’s worth it”.

  6. Dale heyward says:

    No…no…no

  7. Donna says:

    No do not open, build an overpass if anything but do not open!

  8. Roger Lavergne says:

    Finally, an informed opinion! Thank you sir!

  9. 30 steps in any direction takes you to a crosswalk. Are we so lazy that we need to spend millions of tax dollars to save 30 steps. Councillors can make some bone head decisions to waste monies this tops the list

  10. Jean says:

    I am sick of people just moving into Winnipeg who have no idea what it is like to have Portage and Main open telling us that it should be open KEEP IT CLOSED to safe lives.

  11. […] Alyson Shane: The Portage and Main debate is an embarrassment to Winnipeg Menno Zacharias: Should Portage and Main be reopened to pedestrian traffic Design Quarter Winnipeg: A position on the Portage + Main […]

  12. Richard Sparling says:

    Bad idea PERIOD

  13. Karen says:

    I also remember trying to cross in the winter with the ice and wind! NO THANKS … keep it closed!

  14. Doodley Doo says:

    I have yet to come across even one average citizen who thinks this is in any way worth the effort let alone the money to pull it off.
    History will show that it was one of the worst decisions ever, should it happen.

  15. David Adison says:

    I cannot believe this is even a consideration. I know several businesses and corporation located at Portage and main, and all are concerned about losing business underground if this happens.
    Dumb Idea Bowman. Let it go. No point.

  16. Lisa says:

    This intersection should not be reopened to pedestrians. I am a bus driver and people cant even cross properly at all the other intersections correctly. Too much money spend unnecessary when our roads are crumbling and getting bandaid fixes or other areas getting fixed and then not even 1 year later same area torn up because it wasnt done properly! Stop while we’re ahead because reopening this will wreak havoc and I’m sure u want a death pol tally on your head Bowman! Bad idea!

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.